Shiny Moon Cafe

4164 Main St 2nd Floor, Fish Creek, WI 54212, United States
$$$ Cafe
(98 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

If you find yourself wandering through the charming streets of Fish Creek, Wisconsin, be sure to make a stop at Shiny Moon Cafe, a delightful haven for coffee lovers and brunch enthusiasts. Nestled on the second floor at 4164 Main St, this cozy cafe offers a serene escape paired with stunning views of the surrounding landscape.

Shiny Moon Cafe is renowned for its inviting atmosphere, complete with ample natural light that pours in, creating a warm and welcoming space. The decor is casual yet charming, making it the perfect spot to relax with a good book or enjoy a gathering with friends. Customers rave about the friendly service, with staff eager to cater to your needs and share their recommendations.

The menu is a delightful exploration of classic comfort food that elevates your breakfast experience. Start your day off right with their Egg Salad or the Terragon Chicken Salad, both of which showcase fresh, wholesome ingredients. If you're looking for something to warm your soul, you can't go wrong with their delightful quiche of the day or the satisfying farmer's breakfast, which has earned rave reviews for its deliciousness without the usual heaviness of typical diner fare. Don't forget to compliment your meal with a cup of their expertly brewed coffee or one of the delightful Hot Tea & Sweets options, including a rich Matcha Latte or decadent Hot Chocolate.

Real customers have shared their love for the cafe, with one satisfied visitor, Dustin Serbin, claiming it's the best coffee spot in town, perfect for a quick breakfast whenever you're in a hurry to explore. Another guest, Luther Snow, praised their healthy yet flavorful dishes, urging newcomers to “search it out” as it's worth your while. Marissa Milone expressed how this cafe has become a family tradition during their annual visits to Door County, emphasizing the quality and warmth found in every visit.

Beyond the delicious menu, Shiny Moon Cafe occasionally hosts local musicians, adding to the vibrant community atmosphere. Whether you choose to enjoy your meal in-house or take it out to the nearby park by the water, the charming ambiance makes every experience special.

The cafe's commitment to quality, customer satisfaction, and its enchanting location makes Shiny Moon Cafe a must-visit destination in Door County. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this gem offers a perfect blend of delicious food and delightful memories waiting to be created.

Service options
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Fast service
Great coffee
Great tea selection
Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Alcohol
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Wine
Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dessert
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Crowd
Tourists
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

08:00 AM - 02:00 PM

Tuesday

08:00 AM - 02:00 PM

Wednesday

Closed

Thursday

Closed

Friday

08:00 AM - 02:00 PM

Saturday

08:00 AM - 02:00 PM

Sunday

08:00 AM - 02:00 PM

98 Reviews
Dustin Serbin

07 Sep 2025

Welp- Had coffee at multiple locations in Fish Creek- THIS IS THE BEST. If you like coffee you can taste, this is the place, if you like a nice comfortable bathroom...this is also the place . If you want a fun quick breakfast and don't have the time to wait 17 hours in line at White Gull for French toast, this is a really nice alternative to have a day doing stuff and not waiting to eat something...just saying. I loved it!

Luther Snow

28 Aug 2025

This might be the best breakfast in Door County. Delicious and wholesome. We had the farmer's breakfast which had better taste and none of the typical grease. The quiche of the day was unique and delicious. Great coffee too, all in a lovely second floor space overlooking the museum courtyard. Search it out , you'll be glad you did.

Kristen greazel

18 Aug 2025

My iced vanilla latte was unusually delicious. Homemade quiche - which was the special today was absolutely stunning! Great atmosphere in the second floor shop but I walked down to the water and ate my breakfast in the park. Staff was very friendly! I also kind of wanted to try a cheese scone! Prices were high but that can be expected in door county during high season.

Marissa Milone

16 Aug 2025

My fiancé and I absolutely LOVE this place! Every year our family comes to Door County, and we make it a point to go out of our way and come to breakfast here at least once (more than once if we’re being honest). The food is delicious, the coffee hot and iced well, and there’s always a little salad that comes with your food which feels great. It’s a very cute shop that never fails to delight. The lemon lavender cookie, the cheddar milk biscuits, and the Kalua pork sandwich are our top favorites and must haves. A must stop in Door County! I really love how there’s a 15% gratuity automatically implemented too because that’s what should be the normal anyways, and it makes sure that staff are being properly accommodated at all times. Love it! Kudos to Shiny Moon

hannah Smith

24 Jul 2025

Love this spot Located in the heart of Fish Creek… the perfect place to go to grab a delicious bite, menu items include egg dishes, quiches, cookies, scones and the best coffee around. Service with a smile and on some Saturday mornings you’ll be lucky enough to have some Entertainment from local musicians who have made this cozy spot their gathering place. The owner dishes out delicious meals and it can take a little time for her and the staff to prepare. It’s not fast food it’s food lovingly made just for you! Be patient, enjoy. Know there is 15% gratuity included when you order. I have no problem with that! (It’s not 20% and people are working toward college funds !!! Help them out!) That’s what we do when we come to a small town! Slow down, enjoy the experience. Old school! I love it! Oh… they have added a grab and go cooler this summer! Come grab something to take along on your hike, day at the beach or travels home!

Jessamine Burch

20 Jul 2025

Stunning location with beautiful natural light, even on a rainy morning. The food was really wonderful and the coffee was amazing! We will absolutely be back.

Mary Freda-Flores

14 Jul 2025

My sister and I make an annual trip to Door County. This time, we discovered the fabulous Shiny Moon Cafe. The biscuits are amazing with a delightful, buttery, cheesy flavor. You can tell everything here is made with care. We enjoyed the scones. When we visited, they had lemon/blueberry and cherry/almond. I especially enjoyed the Mexican drip coffee with a splash of oat milk. The prices are beyond reasonable for such wholesome food. Our favorite was the classic breakfast sandwich. The aioli has a bit of a kick to it, but the flavor is divine and complements the sandwich well. We dined in the cafe and took sandwiches to go — both times we were pleased with the sandwich! We also loved the balsamic on the side of mixed greens; it has a hint of sweetness that helps offset the vinegary-tang. There is a variety of seating upstairs and music playing in the background at a comfortable level. The staff is lovely — very kind, thoughtful and quick. Add the Shiny Moon to your must-stop list!

Jeremy Thompson

05 Jul 2025

This fantastic hidden gem was amazing. With a small and unique breakfast menu that was bursting with great options and great service! You can’t go wrong at this counter order and sit coffee shop. Craig and I highly recommend stopping in here. We both had the “Eggs in Purgatory” which I enjoyed very much. Not sure about Craig, as he wouldn’t tell me his review. I will definitely bring my wife (Not Craig) here the next time we are in Fish Creek!

Join the Shiny Moon Cafe Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.